• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • About
  • Contact
    • Speaking Request

Benjamin Kerensa

The Ramblings of a Beautiful Mind

Development

Firefox OS and Ubuntu Touch: Who Will Prevail at MWC13?

February 24, 2013 By Benjamin Kerensa

Firefox OS Home ScreenWe are all aware of the current mobile duopoly which is iOS and Android, but at the Mobile World Congress or MWC13, as its commonly being called, there will be a line up of two platforms that attendees will be eager to have a look at: Firefox OS and Ubuntu. Indeed there will be other contenders like Tizen and Sailfish OS, but let’s be honest, if any two open source platforms have a chance of breaking up the mobile duopoly, the best bet is in Firefox OS and Ubuntu Touch.

So between Firefox OS and Ubuntu Touch which platform will have the most buzz? I’m betting on Firefox OS considering their platform is mature. has a great line up of apps, and perhaps the better development tools when compared to Ubuntu Touch, which seems to be building its platform on using a mashup of Cyanogenmod and demo applications that are mostly just a UI shell and for all purposes are demoware.

Performance

I have tried out the Ubuntu Touch image on a Galaxy Nexus device. I have also had multiple opportunities to test the Firefox OS platform on development devices, Comparing the two, I found the Firefox OS UI not only to be much faster and more fluid to the Touch, but months ago, when I was playing around with Firefox OS, it was much more mature than the Ubuntu Touch platform is today.

Apps

Firefox OS already has a impressive line up of apps available in the Firefox Marketplace, many of which are officially supported by the service providers. Ubuntu Touch mostly has non-functional demo applications and has no official support from the likes of Twitter, Evernote and other major services. In fact, just a few days ago I asked someone at Canonical whether they even had permission to use the  trademarked branding of Twitter, Facebook and Skype and they had no clue and thought that the trademark policies of these brands would openly allow them to use the brands and make a show like there was official support from these brands for the Ubuntu Touch platform.

Development Advocacy

Firefox OS set out from the start to not only provide excellent developer tools to contributors but also to host events worldwide to support and accelerate app development by supporting its local communities worldwide through the Mozilla Reps program. Ubuntu has yet to use and empower its LoCo’s (Local Communities) to host events and bring potential developers into the fold.

Firefox OS boasts a emulator for the Ubuntu Desktop yet Ubuntu Phone has no comparable emulator so developers can test their apps and see how they function.

Openness

Firefox OS has been an open platform from the start and has had a very open dialogue with its community while Ubuntu Touch has seen a lot of behind the scenes privacy and limited involvement with the Ubuntu Community. It would seem this walled garden approach that Canonical has taken in launching the Ubuntu Touch platform may have actually hindered progress.

Firefox OS being a project of Mozilla, which is a non-profit, is also better geared to be a more open and transparent platform considering that Mozilla does not have the same commercial aspirations that Canonical has.

Privacy

Mozilla has been touted as one of the most trusted internet companies when it comes to user privacy while Canonical has faced criticism both from its community and from the greater open source community for privacy fails in its Unity dash. It is unclear what impact the privacy concerns that were raised by the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Free Software Foundation will have when it comes to consumers making decisions on whether to trust this mobile data with a platform that Canonical controls and seems unwilling to bend to community feedback.

“I’m astonished by Canonical’s blatant disregard for providing a way to opt-in to this gaping privacy hole. This is a dramatic case of “calling home”, and provides a large amount of information about the user, in real-time.” pointed out Kees Cook, Google Developer and Former Ubuntu Security Engineer in his blog post.

Conclusion

I think Canonical has a long way to go not only from the app development aspect and refining their platform, but also in ensuring that end-users and the community feel like Canonical is being receptive to their concerns, because at the end of the day, Canonical is not buying the product. It’s the users and community members that have the buying power and the power to advocate for the platform being more greatly adopted.

As for Firefox OS, I believe all the right moves are being made and that’s clearly being shown with how remarkable the product is becoming already and how much interest has already been built surrounding the platform and the fact that Firefox OS has a thriving developer community while Ubuntu’s is still in an infancy stage.

Notably, I have been very critical as of late towards the decisions Canonical has been making with Ubuntu. These criticisms are not a result of my distaste for Canonical, but instead because Canonical has made poor decisions of which they have admitted to me in private. I think Canonical has an excellent opportunity to make excellent choices going forward. These choices will allow Ubuntu to be the platform that Mark Shuttleworth fondly talks about with buzzwords and the same platform that Ubuntu community members like myself and others also envision.

 

Filed Under: Mozilla, Open Source, Technology, Ubuntu Tagged With: Android, Apps, Cyanogenmod, Development, Firefox OS, iOS, Marketing, Mobile World Congress, MWC13, Ubuntu Touch

Patch to Fix Unity Shopping Lens Bug Ignored

January 10, 2013 By Benjamin Kerensa

I have to really commend Kees Cook who has made the most sensible suggestions to address the issues that the EFF and others raised about the Unity Shopping Lens. In fact Kees submitted a patch back in November which would fix this bug and the patch as you can see below is quite sane but it has been ignored. Why?
[cc lang=”python”]
=== modified file ‘data/com.canonical.Unity.Lenses.gschema.xml.in.in’
— data/com.canonical.Unity.Lenses.gschema.xml.in.in 2012-09-25 15:10:07 +0000
+++ data/com.canonical.Unity.Lenses.gschema.xml.in.in 2012-11-13 19:36:25 +0000
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@

– ‘all’
+ ‘none’

Content fetching from remote source preference.

“all” is to enable the supported default lens to search from remote and commercial sources. “none” will indicate the lenses to not perform that remote search at all.
[/cc]

Why is the Unity Team not accepting this patch? If they disagree with it they can comment and reject but to just let it sit there for months seems like they have no interest in addressing a valid bug.

Filed Under: Technology, Ubuntu Tagged With: Bug, Development, Shopping Lens, Unity

Ubuntu on Air: Come Ask Questions

July 26, 2012 By Benjamin Kerensa

Join us this Today at 1800 UTC for Ubuntu on Air

Last cycle we decided to just hang out after a release, and we had such a good time and learned so much from our guests that we’re doing it again!

Hosts: Jose Antonio Rey, Jorge Castro, Benjamin Kerensa, and Alan Pope

Guests:

  • Barton George from Dell will be dropping by to talk a little bit about Project Sputnik, Dell’s new developer laptop initiative.
  • Steve Langasek from the Canonical Foundations team will be answering secure-boot related questions, and explaining what’s going on in this space.
  • Leann Ogasawara, Canonical Kernel Team – For all your kernel-related questions.
  • Chris VanHoof, Canonical Hardware Enablement Team – Chris will answer all your hardware questions, including how we roll with nVidia, Intel, and AMD.
  • Robert Carr, Canonical Web Applications Team – Robert will be answering all your questions about web applications.
  • Brian Murray, Ubuntu Defect Analyst, Foundations – Brian will be available to talk about how the Ubuntu teams manages your bug reports.
  • Michael Hall from the Ubuntu Community Team is going to talk about application developers, the application contest, and what it takes to judge 140+ new pieces of software for Ubuntu.
  • …. and of course Jono Bacon, the Ubuntu Community Manager will drop by to answer general questions you might have about Ubuntu and his latest project, Ubuntu Accomplishments!

 

You can watch Ubuntu on Air live and ask questions by visiting http://www.UbuntuonAir.com

 

Filed Under: Linux, Open Source, Technology, Ubuntu Tagged With: Dell, Development, On Air, Ubuntu

Primary Sidebar

Search the blog

Follow Me

  • Facebook
  • Github
  • Instagram
  • Medium
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Subscribe to me on YouTube

Sponsors

Subscribe

It’s easy to get my free tips on Open Source Software, Programming, Community Management and more.

Advertisement

Recent Comments

  • sadasd on Remembering Gerv Markham
  • Roger on Ubuntu Mobile and Desktop Success Zooms Out of Reach
  • Links 8/4/2017: Qt 5.9 Beta, Neptune 4.5.4, Open Build Service 2.8, Deepin 15.4 RC2 | Techrights on Ubuntu Mobile and Desktop Success Zooms Out of Reach
  • jjmarin96 on Ubuntu Mobile and Desktop Success Zooms Out of Reach
  • teh 1 on Ubuntu Mobile and Desktop Success Zooms Out of Reach

Copyright © 2019 Benjamin Kerensa